{"scorecards":[{"agent_id":"quality_gate_evidence","composite_score":0.6632,"dimensions":{"quality":0.968,"efficiency":1.0,"contribution":0.192,"precision":0.1881},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5474,"best_hypothesis_score":0.675,"debates_participated":67,"hypotheses_linked":101,"high_quality_hypotheses":19,"total_tokens":0,"avg_tokens_per_task":1,"avg_latency_ms":0}},{"agent_id":"quality_gate_score","composite_score":0.6632,"dimensions":{"quality":0.968,"efficiency":1.0,"contribution":0.192,"precision":0.1881},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5474,"best_hypothesis_score":0.675,"debates_participated":67,"hypotheses_linked":101,"high_quality_hypotheses":19,"total_tokens":0,"avg_tokens_per_task":1,"avg_latency_ms":0}},{"agent_id":"quality_gate_specificity","composite_score":0.6632,"dimensions":{"quality":0.968,"efficiency":1.0,"contribution":0.192,"precision":0.1881},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5474,"best_hypothesis_score":0.675,"debates_participated":67,"hypotheses_linked":101,"high_quality_hypotheses":19,"total_tokens":0,"avg_tokens_per_task":1,"avg_latency_ms":0}},{"agent_id":"skeptic","composite_score":0.594,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9015,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":1.0,"precision":0.1672},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5098,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":349,"hypotheses_linked":317,"high_quality_hypotheses":53,"total_tokens":19330664,"avg_tokens_per_task":24625.0,"avg_latency_ms":52931.0}},{"agent_id":"domain_expert","composite_score":0.5929,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9019,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.9943,"precision":0.1667},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.51,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":347,"hypotheses_linked":318,"high_quality_hypotheses":53,"total_tokens":32169777,"avg_tokens_per_task":44742.0,"avg_latency_ms":57658.0}},{"agent_id":"theorist","composite_score":0.592,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9034,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.9857,"precision":0.1672},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5109,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":344,"hypotheses_linked":317,"high_quality_hypotheses":53,"total_tokens":56852751,"avg_tokens_per_task":69587.0,"avg_latency_ms":62408.0}},{"agent_id":"synthesizer","composite_score":0.5918,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9004,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.9885,"precision":0.1693},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5092,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":345,"hypotheses_linked":313,"high_quality_hypotheses":53,"total_tokens":18429649,"avg_tokens_per_task":26366.0,"avg_latency_ms":56492.0}},{"agent_id":"falsifier","composite_score":0.5571,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9782,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.6246,"precision":0.2045},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5532,"best_hypothesis_score":0.675,"debates_participated":218,"hypotheses_linked":88,"high_quality_hypotheses":18,"total_tokens":23972145,"avg_tokens_per_task":90121.0,"avg_latency_ms":80332.0}},{"agent_id":"computational_biologist","composite_score":0.479,"dimensions":{"quality":1.0,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0201,"precision":0.375},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5655,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":7,"hypotheses_linked":8,"high_quality_hypotheses":3,"total_tokens":1634653,"avg_tokens_per_task":60543.0,"avg_latency_ms":27664.0}},{"agent_id":"epidemiologist","composite_score":0.4571,"dimensions":{"quality":0.9927,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0143,"precision":0.2857},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.5614,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":5,"hypotheses_linked":7,"high_quality_hypotheses":2,"total_tokens":4015705,"avg_tokens_per_task":160628.0,"avg_latency_ms":36490.0}},{"agent_id":"clinical_trialist","composite_score":0.3688,"dimensions":{"quality":0.8561,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0344,"precision":0.0976},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.4841,"best_hypothesis_score":0.78,"debates_participated":12,"hypotheses_linked":41,"high_quality_hypotheses":4,"total_tokens":6483934,"avg_tokens_per_task":54949.0,"avg_latency_ms":29439.0}},{"agent_id":"medicinal_chemist","composite_score":0.3362,"dimensions":{"quality":0.8332,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0143,"precision":0.0},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0.4712,"best_hypothesis_score":0.5754,"debates_participated":5,"hypotheses_linked":8,"high_quality_hypotheses":0,"total_tokens":6227434,"avg_tokens_per_task":117499.0,"avg_latency_ms":30576.0}},{"agent_id":"assumption_challenger","composite_score":0.0006,"dimensions":{"quality":0.0,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0029,"precision":0.0},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0,"best_hypothesis_score":0,"debates_participated":1,"hypotheses_linked":0,"high_quality_hypotheses":0,"total_tokens":33822,"avg_tokens_per_task":33822.0,"avg_latency_ms":59457.0}},{"agent_id":"evidence_auditor","composite_score":0.0006,"dimensions":{"quality":0.0,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0029,"precision":0.0},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0,"best_hypothesis_score":0,"debates_participated":1,"hypotheses_linked":0,"high_quality_hypotheses":0,"total_tokens":76987,"avg_tokens_per_task":76987.0,"avg_latency_ms":87811.0}},{"agent_id":"generalizability_assessor","composite_score":0.0006,"dimensions":{"quality":0.0,"efficiency":0.0,"contribution":0.0029,"precision":0.0},"raw_metrics":{"avg_hypothesis_score":0,"best_hypothesis_score":0,"debates_participated":1,"hypotheses_linked":0,"high_quality_hypotheses":0,"total_tokens":32474,"avg_tokens_per_task":32474.0,"avg_latency_ms":35810.0}}],"weights":{"quality":0.4,"efficiency":0.2,"contribution":0.2,"precision":0.2},"generated_at":"2026-04-16T09:27:59.211948"}