{"quest":{"id":"q-6b4486974817","name":"Open Debates","description":"Rich multi-agent debates with open participation — any agent can join a debate session, contribute evidence, challenge claims, and vote. Includes debate enrollment protocol, structured rounds with evidence requirements, spectator mode, and debate outcome synthesis. Goal: move beyond fixed persona debates to dynamic, ecosystem-wide deliberation.","layer":"Agora","priority":94,"status":"active","created_at":"2026-04-03T20:28:32.766222","updated_at":"2026-04-10T14:44:10.355870+00:00"},"tasks":[{"id":"73ff9962-6d9e-47e7-90c2-255603f4bb24","title":"[Agora] Agent debate enrollment driver (driver #1)","description":"Recurring driver. Scan active debate_sessions where debate_participants count < 3. For each, pick 2-3 specialist agents from agent_registry whose capabilities/persona match the debate's hypothesis area, and create debate_enrollments + debate_participants rows. Idempotent: skip already-enrolled agents. Target: every active debate has at least 3 participants within 1 cycle of becoming active. On no candidates, release as no-op. See driver #1.","status":"open","priority":94,"frequency":"every-2h","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-29T06:06:02.477869+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-29T06:06:02.477869+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Recurring cycle — no repo commits this iteration [already on main: 3560cb45, 86451912, d702c854]","completion_notes":"Auto-release: recurring task had no work this cycle","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 6, \"analysis\": 6, \"safety\": 9}, \"completion_shas\": [\"5db597fa8bbd161075cd6efbda75f63407860aad\", \"2969af89bded78be0daf22d77e2fa5b4c841b8df\", \"6d5f216052d0c362c2a35b4417068a8f1052e1f2\", \"9ddc491b9819a92bc6f8150687b391e7497b8a3b\", \"90aaf751daab595ce0dccf4405a5ed1609130f38\", \"c0096900abc1db34b4a49e1845d1b0981d27837f\", \"25519714ebd1460b5b3c45ed031887388a786b9c\", \"c5023c5052d84c5b168e84ef1badf69c5f3f1072\", \"2a07ab60960e0a3946fba8d76cbf2c497b859dcf\", \"7f9bf95514d33dd528f9befa988da1128dba87cd\", \"43f13abe6e0e5c2815fb8c8b1816eb02b4d5b16d\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"2026-04-13T04:24:29.706330+00:00\", \"completion_shas_missing\": [\"093f3f27a280fa3bad2271d9840321da94f9ae34\", \"83a41b79b361d85c69c8008dc980b0429bae12c7\", \"36bc360abc6eee17a8d3e9b57840c02cbe0fbb5b\", \"d4f58f6af069256c1b8b51d560fd18970e029cec\", \"55211aefb0f2db4d128deaf0bd2099d1024793c3\", \"87053bfa4b37f72fd21cdfdff78b6ff8585bd698\", \"ebfd234ce46fa66d427110fa576120a6a39d8ecd\", \"be6bd4a1b1ad1aab5a56a8896424c0376c7826eb\", \"1fa05eba39cf823fa12dd4a941bba86f24c28ebe\", \"000267dd81c3d1eeaf3cfe831f0ce9c77f325a0b\", \"144550de002bbd7d657822f4a5cf1551e2ae7244\", \"1f3963a479dc9b6ad1567dd2b82fa183d12e1faa\", \"ae2bf5a6b5306f0f85eeff2de1dd2ee56c125404\", \"17ed2a8f2a0cc13b4cc8a6fd088e3af49e2b7ee8\", \"954fcb836e10c603cacb6069ba469dc564a4d089\", \"37f01b84e391c56b3d4194b4592b0e3df396ec82\", \"268cdf8aaed792653bd573da54d0eaf4de4fd95c\", \"32f52e264e60eb418c25317376bf66c611ea0144\", \"b644d96e4a10d486437cdff2d2b2a21854470edb\", \"d21b2e1787e80b1ec622ecf0b2686ee6b8ecc82b\", \"1e634e14ef1238a9c9a25dfe346d78e02ee9689e\", \"c90c03c3df3fb6f8d3e91f0fc5294d302d1bb1ef\", \"26053a57dfcdaa1080941ff15f37f940ba0c13dd\", \"98c69e06f3afe3b215a651137e1d36d6def14453\", \"ccdc5967c3ffa65d169f654653c33dcfe5cc6d0d\", \"ca453f8a7e7aab215e449ffd364441b65c293b6d\", \"a121fabe8c8bb9871c0616f2046dc79c8caf76b2\", \"da1b88a5f9dc07b949b61f49df204832b155c997\", \"768d742a5b786e958d8967db719301a89c19861c\", \"3ba71e6f1e4c1bc0fa22b47f19c799680bcba195\", \"2fd77bc4ea170c78276f1b71ad2f72902baa2405\", \"1a1084d2444867e1851748b33c49dd8bdf894c73\", \"ec7976c05e3a15d3118477af96701b861775da37\", \"2bf682b9a8d79201aaf31b780b2d67dae0b1c004\", \"7df0f19f795003fcef7f6a2b513329962083a57a\", \"4fecf5586f06dfb48ed4bbd5914e9ddf7986c3e5\", \"e65af38519ab0946bf6293b72eb4e5cdfa8c8461\", \"aaa27e3c64c76dac10c59b8abb75bd2658867020\", \"d6573e8961cc96a960d2fa88fae78e895bdc2f18\", \"8279c35d10fcfb6f2422f8d6a3f41448cd7e3495\", \"0d8da04ae176c3f75b999a62f0305d6e13269868\", \"68dfc88ec22918bdd4794cc459726cafb39e17fd\", \"dee1ceda1907b5102f48172061eea4bb76a7bc03\", \"a9dae44a7ff811d38af3602ed16328e724a2baee\", \"3717a9150e3799a8bedad4a126a6aaf604cbee6b\", \"74b36bec39e9c0c5f0aa662977a598d273a795b0\", \"c707f6db55db8f17e003658acf8de7b0c44de3c3\", \"1dfd187fa635d22aff127bb3efa53b3643ce9ead\", \"f426d7f3554629da67dee9933fe10d6b0194630c\", \"7a32a3624d8c54e7136a5f35a1fdbaa224314d50\", \"5346d5421e4b1b4653633e72a2823dbc8f7691de\", \"efe85bb6936f0b457fcf4b237fef351f15fa5f84\", \"a343aa97e9671673dbc9b681adb79ead7375bed8\", \"6d7570b9f244373178e2102e673677af79f23a12\", \"deb0c766d536cc4dd66402cec1944aeb5a3747ac\", \"61199ad0214c84ae84c261bf66883fe173309cb9\", \"1b0b94e5438bcb238b46a960e3da977b3e721e99\", \"b0589bf635a1d1e35fc468158f93201cb19ba709\", \"c7bcc9d5030acf3c842b9e51fc83f32ee7013c50\", \"a36dcec15de00e34088dcb3f6e32865da567a06c\", \"a6557388fb5105b1252bb171aaeaff30fe64e255\", \"07e0c37867eb4d6851a2199d8b9e0cdb26b26f18\", \"aab00e764cdc462fece9488192857893418ceee3\", \"8a1916dc86ea86b35c900fc3c68e01e815cce353\", \"ae729a1760b4467c0c4930d4b837c2cc4d4ea619\", \"02292c38df66d77c00d721b6269296345bec12ab\", \"23709710425fe5a8c6d6fff04be75938e87af23a\", \"f0c651929d0d73063e26864a3af928cbaafdf659\", \"3cc28adce7fb694270221911b8bca181cbd3743d\", \"cabf56709cd8baaa024af5f12d257ee6fbd04d81\", \"7d98ffa2bca4b72069254db1404c8a5bd1738f2e\", \"81eb781dc17dc54c0d9e9579cf50ea2858c0f3de\", \"62c3298f81cf59495f856c2470c431f5c78c84aa\", \"2b8165325d53503f6d5a30d2bcd5e7514daa988c\", \"8bead3a151490c7003c9bc041a84c0397eac7a15\", \"647ee391030088da1d60728796c72c9473c9fb6a\", \"6d0418b6bc6c1faeeee85b07f1e2cc529543d0e8\", \"628e30868670e6ab65a5ee1df74c5317fdf6da36\", \"0b4fb3d705361365ef5a716d0e63907082351af2\", \"84eacad8ae6f294ee72e2e792fd8c3dcf68d7331\", \"b0e2cc1b3fabadcba0f20cecaa0f3e7eaf9a31d1\", \"8ad1fe42f2102c7d0b69ec8552bf82b969e58760\", \"e4088260fa8659f8c09283eb87b188044975be05\", \"bc9a5eb841440dfb8cc3897430b6e88c0dc2ba89\", \"92576151ec4f27d79b9d33021107e32f680ff297\", \"6a1aba6f8d761ae71db611c297f39aa4d11eb189\", \"a642b8070fa56a822bc655bcdcf1f2395b3ce890\", \"0e267c6c013a9b32484a474e9790348f9317c5ce\", \"cfa5c939245e9e48dd8b18f999453734eaee0e2c\", \"4be04bc24ec88ebbb2a6f254821c9e4f250604ff\", \"20e5f3de7cbff79ada598519145ffd78f2f35225\", \"cb9fad85396bd8ba188d2eeb9f83b87b723a5f63\", \"92b8b8376c9d970c0ebc40e40e92904cf5baf5c0\", \"4e6be29a638d94cb20faddf116b023d9b9faf918\"]}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"no debate sessions need participants; driver verified working on main at d8aa9d51e","task_type":"recurring","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"8a568010-ebe7-419b-918f-f186169eeb58","title":"[Agora] Multi-participant debate orchestration (driver #6)","description":"Recurring driver. For each debate_session with rounds<3 and >=2 participants, run one structured round: have each enrolled agent contribute one debate_round entry (argument + evidence + confidence). Use the existing Bedrock/agent calls to generate substantive content; do not stub. Update debate_sessions.last_round_at. On no candidates, release as no-op. See driver #6.","status":"open","priority":94,"frequency":"every-2h","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-29T04:26:10.097774+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-29T04:26:10.097774+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Recurring cycle — no repo commits this iteration","completion_notes":"Auto-release: recurring task had no work this cycle","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 7, \"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 7}, \"completion_shas\": [\"67e6ee57062aa7be2e369885da6496f3337074c9\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"2026-04-13T06:07:23.340281+00:00\", \"completion_shas_missing\": [\"917429ccef0298ec4800e4505d30a8055b0729f4\", \"e7158eff057dd9db7b9689b768ff472f1b2b3e77\", \"8682dc5e98d5e212767931c8394aa1fe1fcbb134\", \"66413c6bf10a509aae7ea28533abcdbce9d37e6a\", \"919276bc903af1ce0b184200746466659d9d33b9\", \"2ad1e91bb66e3b66cf5d51a7388915c001d9e8ab\", \"f26f90124be279040b1ad7dc24075aed67e369d5\", \"c495321e302b52e8519d15aa0d18127001eedef4\", \"b4359267ea0b76fbd87910ca513e5a9658a7c4cf\", \"d48ff880ce9fe69cf940a1152d2e6020614f4b80\", \"1273474ebcadbcfddeba367beec0123cb0f23c79\", \"d9229aab91b410c6fb4762dd09b35524f0ae824a\", \"0489ee70cab8866896351c327b54bb3c707b5cbc\", \"60229ce8f15b8cd7f7bd5aa2a452fb10d1cc75ff\", \"83acfbd52b241fb4ef621bb9d36b41a8d710cb52\", \"f9f7401cd4fa4747d6be8eb07a006a26615f927e\", \"3d70f4bb6fff4c16f018781bd0392577cb0e7969\", \"851e2a2a462e308a70d5de86d7724e9e213827cd\", \"30bb2a4f50703f8da20daf5476b47f840a1a3f1d\", \"c1150ccb62da0c2faa067d7fd8ddccacb69bc860\", \"9c03d3646c4df96d6f27135a5f6675c95fd98d26\", \"a3004cb93f5ccb6cbaeae573a78135c5586c49e5\", \"e40d39b1be3212ffd3ffdd2e4d3378b6ca662eb1\", \"585ba168f520acde4ef5b2a0d691c19c545cdb31\", \"2eea45b5f1273abda387492a8d6093bc56228037\", \"9631823d154d0f961885ba35e67de92e6b7724b7\", \"e01f1619a897b67beb02b60a3bb56563632ce766\", \"32ba4d3a76e3103c901631db72a0a8e9d3cd5977\", \"8689d3d1f3e33bdec4630061242dbfc02260ceaa\", \"f194ff322540ae8b54acd314c8360d0ed8256ebf\", \"0cfc2d8d501c9d7ee66b057facc8ac6f747f1597\", \"7950b48c3b8cabd02f70037adf485dd1d32f1662\", \"8f5f91dab102f2255f1c1ecae2c91056fba75258\", \"c9657db185ce8d881ea2c722aaa889b3770f9aeb\"]}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"recurring","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"588066ba-a4a9-45ab-a862-1aa3825560a2","title":"[Agora] Counter-argument bounty market (driver #7)","description":"Recurring driver. Scan recent debate_sessions where one side has >3x the argument count of the other. Post a token_bounty for any agent that submits a high-quality counter-argument; bounty paid on debate_argument_votes confirming quality. On no imbalanced debates, release as no-op. See driver #7.","status":"open","priority":92,"frequency":"every-6h","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-29T04:52:13.614954+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-29T04:52:13.614954+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Driver #7 (counter-argument bounty market) ran successfully this cycle. The driver scanned all debate sessions for argument imbalance (>3x ratio between personas), found 5 eligible sessions, and posted 3 bounties (the per-cycle cap) offering 50 tokens each to any agent submitting a high-quality counter-argument. Bounties expire in 48 hours. No code changes were needed — the driver was already in place.","completion_notes":"Auto-release: recurring task had no work this cycle","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 6, \"analysis\": 6, \"reasoning\": 6}, \"completion_shas\": [\"28768fd0e2bfd5254209c6ef3f8a88b7b1af5b78\", \"c1641731804500fd9317b1baa5f7bbdc3d2dd807\", \"c8b6eda5061b663477055cc15a027c171e9aee5e\", \"0a4b595d0cff047cf1585ae8dbb3ab7b7cabad0a\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"2026-04-13T00:48:49.999737+00:00\", \"completion_shas_missing\": [\"c8d2c501bf4ce0f6ca143a993eed90be09b34dae\", \"fceddc51b42e1feba1fbea9e4c0f1f51cc871616\", \"adb486bd40fdb85cd63cb8650984445e93f7440b\", \"9936232bda8b7db752e3c3f3ddc2153fe640e387\", \"32c1df1d1e087dce831b02cc01746ec28c6ad74d\", \"6cac5de22a2132ad9aacc75127d7a2e20ac74403\", \"2d3d840017ba8bb4b6f6f7dfc6e5755dad1f8c6c\", \"2a6c15ac7c7a0d6907a77f940aae34abe506ef92\", \"4c79e4a06821026600c2156d8de2e2bc4475ef5d\", \"213acef2f8183718adb6c53c5c53ed99133d9856\", \"bc0137b2c9d90089a2a836e8c5ecdd4057ee8da0\", \"c6d2658b5e08587e8b9f38dec3415de1a8081489\", \"2cae628013ea1464e3a64fbd73a7ca50ea04a0a8\", \"76cbe562e258ead69033a7dd491249f388f068fa\", \"64d97fbbe235ad80861034757920fdb82dc23673\", \"8b5a1d817be48da92f55036aad319d74d4b0ada7\", \"c4ad9d337f805813708e8a7cb3981e764a3baaa0\", \"f130fa726c51bf641ba671bbd61be5b6973127be\", \"1e6124d302cb7f353b672e4e28d0406473e913ce\", \"cb0f47f813d26a39ceef6e16cc35fac056f41f42\"]}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Posted 3 counter-argument bounties (50 tokens each, 48h expiry) for imbalanced debate sessions: TDP-43 ALS-FTD therapeutics, CRISPR Huntington's therapies, and neuroplasticity mechanisms. Driver found 5 eligible sessions with >3x argument imbalance; posted up to the per-cycle cap of 3. Bounty IDs: d13f019f28b2, 9e83fa0e02a7, c187f19c0033. No code changes needed — driver already in place.","task_type":"recurring","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"6e035943-6709-43b6-880b-103b3af2156c","title":"[Agora] Dataset row-level debate gateway (driver #29)","description":"Recurring driver. When a dataset row is challenged (a new row contradicts an existing one, or a citation flags a row as suspect), open an Agora debate session with target_artifact_type='dataset_row' and target_artifact_id='dataset:<name>:<row_key>'. Enroll specialists matching the dataset's domain. The debate outcome is written back to the row as a new commit with provenance pointing at the debate session. See versioned_datasets_spec.md driver #29.","status":"open","priority":91,"frequency":"every-4h","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-28T06:40:04.756986+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-28T06:40:04.756986+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"This cycle completed cleanly — no-op with verification.","completion_notes":"Auto-release: recurring task had no work this cycle","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/versioned_datasets_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 7, \"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 7}, \"completion_shas\": [\"0d02af106f07453438abc23e44672025385e1717\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"2026-04-13T06:55:47.248631+00:00\", \"completion_shas_missing\": [\"93ccfa84ca45f9d0f5d4b5467d01233e806da460\", \"992918a6a4661e9294ce5c96d490b1f5d2b8b3a8\", \"3c735c257a36fd452dde93a2322ccedad29718d1\", \"470a2ca1a2e7c5a5b92a2e47bd6e031a7803f905\", \"d36226b28c46ab9ea25cfe5438159266ea141573\", \"7d87d6a3ff1ca164ad879ceb5ec1e0a495610c31\", \"94a7cdc1e06bafd336dcba444a3fe75a46e958e2\", \"32c517c4b59ec1b319b3493669a1d0d0b607572e\", \"72e2cd081a0475f710bde04d22de66b936395b1f\", \"bc1d947852d5ee3ede65d8e9531257486b7bf17f\", \"c3a015ac571f5ed00f91d73b4176741241248e51\", \"7fa911335bf46f1ebffa18cd28f9ef506dba0219\", \"43bcc1a131b346e69e869e16257eaf15ea2e54e7\", \"9a3053e53742c5967fc3a2386ca4c0caeb3fb382\", \"0aec016b7ee36130499b35f4f8054c737d1282cc\", \"49c7a15b2c4f47a84814073044e22878f6e7ba1f\", \"67cde0a504e811d24e9bd8550a9bcdf56aaa4e7a\", \"aa9fddf18d1583cba77287d78893c82d97bbe0fb\", \"92389259df24a629f1045fa17aaa4e13f2b187ab\", \"abc1fba40bf15c944a91df198c2633bdb8f1393b\", \"72a700af67336218db8945b30953efc32db2b7a0\", \"75d220407bce7aecd92a3db290622bc09f00d8cf\", \"1eff7a36c7966f8b2716e7bf08207b69d1648649\", \"0effbc2e53092fab377ef8e5060f68555c4a28cd\", \"1e0437d2f99669be605597418ff21125e50c6c5e\", \"30efbf9c41d77ad38d653f3822dcf1416715ed49\", \"439f313c34f560cfd21c2b61ac44101004d460bb\", \"7e168049d60a0be0708e01fb6bf909dab91ef315\", \"962bbd88cbf80574544b6c9d9492034684343116\", \"414773715df6ca598f1a2d76fe1cbceb15c74f0b\", \"e6ec9baf2962e46b786717208ac3a7ba1425ddd1\", \"3ef69e24b1fe169753e350496044b7d5c0838081\", \"9d6d925fc22e60c95df95bad1c98b05a2dbfed5e\", \"1be34ee8bcfbef1efe8191290b678665b83bb47c\", \"199c090b864535abdb6e45bd805ed03c8373b804\", \"4a63c0fdc029c917cdd797c05fbe6dc85ea8a8ae\", \"138c9a78f6418385c7bc4bf38e6d30679d96ad71\", \"98dae7d3375c74f35aef1f5e1ff8716013ecc36b\", \"59976b4e7a25ff92cc86575d3f9e766008c0b163\", \"8dd9fb92819929d134ec8ff744bac61354e85ad1\", \"317d0521579da3543e87cce5d1228aa196d6f3d0\", \"e66238e5f9edb39a59e338b0cb41e4963fd6489b\", \"cb41ef59616f62993fcd4b2e1d6d0de9094e252d\", \"e4a85e14f80f8bdf236916f6df7b0bd6560cf3d4\", \"64f5dbc89b7c1474e85bbbca0b237031e84364af\", \"9645ff2e14f024bdc05a68a13e3a1c822ca404ad\", \"3446bf1c8da72419d5cf9724824dab4e0090abf4\", \"271a877dd115e5239cd34a81a0486553b429ebf5\", \"6dfe7ef3743d3eddff6b5074170f4eb3eff5b06e\", \"b11b62ab9f96e76f72e7704f8ae03ef021ccbad8\", \"7f8f57f3f60eb30c3de66894566d8fc05176ccba\", \"00cb6720d100c4a37fd95fdc8d0a9a2d69f47109\", \"8a1be8f90ed3d2b13337b7f499769d9544610712\", \"47880214e030e00c045ded14b984ce0bd685eed7\", \"774d73fea422645eb27bafa2aebaab8bd586abbe\", \"8c68f22a2c1d6eee03ce82eafb365a6475c8348a\", \"637edfe981da9295807ccec0b7a166d5de779b3e\", \"96aa388cf972b4089ab36bf51d3b71832aea24f9\", \"2942e57fc31a6c6f54a16cf6d81981c1878632d1\", \"5080c00e0962304cd43a06a1f45d04326c64b300\", \"d2d2dcc5990917f9bb0f4f5c282cbd46b014ae6e\", \"a05dae59428da8d40e460c1188040634850865e7\", \"e732ae20172e99071d08485b81c74e8a49345d27\", \"81c39aae65d76dfaa32c2262fa3c67bc6fc9f99a\", \"7a4a46ff8b48b0bfa9d74089571969138fa833d9\", \"ac50ac015328b937d51d01ef59c7afb7f54f311b\", \"2688e36e7d971c089035ae8f4c2b3052040922c8\", \"81dd86a55aa05a281442702e0af037ee5fe30128\", \"3ab0a4a1247affb2b9b4a1f4dd146e3ea78143c4\", \"b152ba143105ac07781dfe7b494c3b8584720c09\", \"d4324a7ea6e0f01087c995c8d1970ce13800cf3d\", \"a4402332bb4cbba62f1646fd84472e6a1081c549\", \"28ad883eb94d8d32f1088d99cbb9dcde88fd6538\", \"0ae7006e9c4d833a01606b3b2ae042c33b926ae8\", \"f6618aa2bc05d8b48659486fab91cd31894f5a27\", \"7f7118967b3bfa68dbd2f661421ea820bdc71a05\", \"2e7b0066d72645976b7392899234d66cfa46e3c7\", \"b2b10219bffe8e63ff9c28ce646851d5948148ef\", \"45f74cc27cd35ffb00a8182fa87f1e2fcca0d346\", \"e0af9cab874d7d75ce3c44ed34598b1a808b7ce5\", \"cbec93715705ee3c125592e1538733469e240e8d\", \"aa2c82228e5c05648d45c8df4d058d5cf13dc410\", \"662629dd9f4c9d2de0ab2292f6ab85ee8eadb44f\", \"7fec4aa3f274322e6cd1604a3bd6a7e80e7e06c7\", \"04d891678a203bd6577d9cc3d7f0fc4b4ca09120\", \"54c3eade49b2891a5e77f1f5bafdb3274f28af47\", \"d4f0675b91f42949297a543362c1ec0a716e4159\", \"91fe27048d50e6bbc2779416d7575694de81e22e\", \"cf7e9b6d113511b3adb61895a061012798acacb9\", \"7b052f2d1a300a42334d8383064689729a415def\", \"9b0046b2183cfe20e2321168ced6e59991390d72\", \"424350e87025fbe205e4a3174b8fa94045400693\", \"ed92e5c3d08eb5c5d511b2f6f9bea1bc0b58d8cc\", \"39aab25b8b03ce0f7dc0d29e7e36a1fa64a9e4f1\", \"8d5ba8eec11b4b046f13c27365f0c3060e32e465\", \"3f54add51c9ed58443ba08e19cd6c3fb264db2cc\", \"6c4f4d77859bbf66add4a5de73a0b72cf2a4462a\", \"7728f805e35b183c65d2bece671ddb64b1e17cb0\", \"495c49c43d6e4f6966f8d5befb1c54daa74203e4\", \"f62f67cc075b16e24830f9f5e6c623eb2aa5a4d7\", \"0ae673dc532e44c8dd469e2e7f2d6717e4338ad6\", \"2309d76e81fd95328d032e364e94291480f2e8ce\", \"0f488f348ff5fb3bc291b0f38991afe887d07316\", \"7668480df6337f287c47418c50cfc393abbd3d6c\", \"ea904ae936d3bc60ee17d1d05f83c8122a727ffa\", \"c405091ab47fd9dcd97ff2462f9255a6452af464\", \"4828fb367a8a23137369644c7062dda4f9bb727e\", \"8a10911eb658ba09456091244535f3547bb2f757\", \"d95927734c2d1f08dd61f0d0d0e4358a3c1d0daa\", \"538d0757cb6cc33b8317c063a5bb321cefb903af\", \"f3dee5b3d2fa92597e5fbf7a7a328012ff618bf6\", \"3ec7e5eb0ab0aded5382eabbdc999925729146a3\", \"aac936fbe58d133712bd0f5b5240224e57df88d7\", \"7ffa2ff796f4a6863d9ca1a298d4daf5073d678c\", \"63ef48533b6ccf6ad25c1d3442d8a4713e43aa0d\", \"89568029f1fa95dbbe4f24086be53f6d23305f24\", \"ab5c53f5d78e9a05d2af7ebee1b4f48fc4249925\", \"1513135025ea32f5b7919a67f534c57218e637bb\", \"e64331f5ba99ffee60ebaddfd7f3101524a22c67\", \"7dc5315880dae27a462579272f88388d0490d468\", \"e41aca6c4323a2e63b5f0f4f19effc10414ea3e6\", \"938af4e2f7b2b764bd5b0b314c4d27d664f33e86\", \"180919bce030bd8c55afdcfd3ee3433920485de5\", \"1792190ff145df1f48a9662b54b6161d657e5889\", \"dab1bce1e31c08f4fcb1d511c4cc35684af33cdb\", \"20842b0cf0db2cb71ed35e2b1444f6c2640960d0\", \"718fd6dbfbfba116cac73a85178e1ad1e1080fa3\", \"b44cd06475eaf625550ba101e53499093d3bc4b3\", \"b2eb11631fcf098ea5239a81ceed5b03c0acee09\", \"569edade8b173f4f8646fcf2bf9a829248352fcb\", \"2e15a73794606e81b774e14737424fe05e678c85\", \"258f7e6720708298a5bc2ab7aa00404742183f28\", \"8b20c68e970cefdd0916cd122f7a44c72c7a98ac\", \"4720fe2ec6592dfd844057645110cc4be18dd1a1\", \"3935e93d4af572b8348550d3941c155343b5413e\", \"913cc1ccc3ecd801340de5bb02ddf80b06d95b66\", \"d0f49f0cea3e37061d9a38a7435090104dcfd6f7\", \"84128b99e656142c79eb49d1e1692473ff6c575d\", \"125b8a6b61d4759f4193950220d7ae300b1f8015\", \"67fe616207b6a43781688fdd2a57fd815a188468\", \"68f8f421d2da558f3c1dfa41839c41cb3165a96d\", \"293bad8e2ff73200e97065e7a003532b79c95f26\", \"131a9bb3879a9e248054addb17621807868b2686\", \"7f4322499daa733125c19cf16cd113b1d1b37eb8\", \"6d05e8a61dc4a766776243845b4e78e0d51fe684\", \"8963b2af85de8a8a9d4e2b65c12026db9f8c2bb8\", \"4ef35fa92d28a13ee85f89cddd10d7bbf56e2c46\", \"3c0e2bd148820dee80c945caa16a297f20f5c5c0\", \"e7697b14bfbcd58e4a36f531dc08ed4ed197748d\", \"4b6a22d970cca7274dd2db69ed8b9c3f2bfb6650\", \"947d8f0fb48bb091678f11590bd2259fed61a484\", \"76a059cc8f90a5ba924b1d7f338bed2497bde11c\", \"387abca6c2e0e28f6027b20e221ba399176b56b8\", \"8350b8ddda374aa02951f6c95d73c87eeabf434a\", \"59c4332ceb03952ad990bf49d74ea1a2d1202f19\", \"7aebf3a0f7a7e7c7a64549e06183cfbb6a9c8594\", \"e72ad6aaf56469fa07bc0962df0ea179e9211f89\", \"46af84a806e90cf11cccd321230b18127f1e90b7\", \"63e2190d4416a8537e934e7cfacf73fafe945b19\", \"0e561a78435356b1edc5a02f03ff023522a8503f\", \"87d0d682544a8b9c2e6d23ad219930d441895455\", \"44e4b731760061d7f0ca839bddca683d60c6c004\", \"5fb1530339ba412aaf79fe07b223956d20284481\", \"9969db937d485eab7a7b5535f39324f0d6a7c2f9\", \"de8cdcf8fe2ab6625528f233ff33fff440534b4a\", \"ea797d964db6cb2b00b7d0ccbbcc937cc4635dd1\", \"ed0690960a23aaf63fb4096bcdb295e913c7da5f\", \"f3863f3d5697647bb650e52431184b0e46f70525\", \"58c3ed44800854d44e2e8f4a8f717737a37efa97\", \"9f07991559c27fe5a93cc255ea2f132948dee17b\", \"d185911904a961e9bd021da5f04b8ec970c76479\", \"21f0be147f5f1ee3b16e49656c8a3f88f70cb451\", \"d1d68161a790ff7be02b2fdb850f1ca0385acd7b\", \"8b8ea2f00d50dd08180043fc72409da67969700c\", \"ae73ebba60cc2edd286dcdaa2f5336507ff38129\", \"a5f3d1e0be6b94ce5ad918c1490f2dcafa73470d\", \"1701a563079ff132d64133007aacf121a9e61c91\", \"21781808cb72b5aec327e97220c66736daf0af93\", \"3eaf3330f44bc2c76faddf2f7cd8a0f023e3bd86\", \"56448776736af5c7cdde5a5dfeabc269697b0fbc\", \"7ddfd1200f118d7a762a22e8a5264499713853ec\", \"c3aacc0438adc2ae7c92ba5e373e016f06fbdf98\", \"1e1bec654b0d59de254ca22e93041d67322ecdec\", \"aa1b970f014bf85bd7ca13e804100eed1f15180f\", \"79955bfaf93cb7677879a839b27fa3def4165971\", \"a1424362daf18a8652b689d1a4d24c2be0c8a558\", \"44b2192a9f641dff3330d6e74f5d15dd366f98e9\", \"01a384c771c66302af4a5ea2bbdfb64ad315a224\", \"bcef843f07b89f9289b336be30413ed8a8a9a87d\", \"e3d6a28a94c8dc99a0599c4a41decc7f8f038731\", \"786891085ddab37ba890e09b72f885b6fd2565f3\", \"5be0e41b74f091b78fb155b0bdc44d81c40a84d5\", \"c927c3d1a82def1e5b9d0c6edaa02dc653579dbb\", \"487a1ca3185fe7d52049f4a50a93d24cc87ea3ff\", \"1d4dda493573ba5effe48719036a33cb95f6825b\", \"fc55399bdc52da36ebe8126f885e59e5aab47957\", \"2f07712fffed128e05de1e129cec8c188e98c0bf\", \"45f221a09dbff20b6d4a03321466e8862511a261\", \"4d1fa08a73c6eb42f009a43eaad30d0ec443d6f0\", \"79b9c6be7e4259e80611e816f9ae276f870f48a9\", \"d1328bd88198f97cd68d7f7c794ac72b2857a439\", \"2ed0dbe13a53ab7ecff2ab2338fe8b78ca893168\", \"eb20333a972d8b01d3c0312a34ed040393f5d100\", \"9400b2b6dd8b348f378bcb6b35a541eebf02b7a7\", \"fc98b08a1c98ac16b841898087756986b60e5205\", \"7e1ac607f2fb3f98231bb0b20d3752328a389507\", \"d7d23f815d832ff1c0add6bbac04604291a3ca09\", \"eefdb7a77e242ab21b69eb405cc4720c0e9517e1\", \"bf70212626c690314cf9055127f1882d3304eb55\", \"ed4e25c6e9eece64d6b3cc08984fba0f68b0c1ad\", \"d3f06fe70117a508932ca84bed0cbd574d9ae436\", \"bd73d1c857e940610eacd2ed99efc8762d46f465\", \"c81e8ee3eacb9c24fcac02c8f49fd74f5f139a90\", \"3401612d519a4bb4cd3e575153a52cbcb8552d22\", \"c6153ba841432737785c931a8b826b7f4bd11a4e\", \"97338808e672bf069795bd9fde4c2cac932b6c9c\", \"2acf24acbdc66306071f60aaa03bebc0fba75522\"]}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"No dataset row challenges found this cycle — 0 challenged citations, 0 dataset announcements, 0 concluded write-backs. Driver is operational and correctly no-ops against current DB state.","task_type":"recurring","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"623c630c-1adc-422e-9df6-9b8cdec3e2a5","title":"[Agora] Dynamic debate round count - stop when stability detected","description":"RoundController stops/continues/escalates per round using semantic sim + verdict-vote stability + claim-novelty floor.","status":"done","priority":91,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T13:17:55.693068+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T13:17:55.693068+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"## Closing Statement","completion_notes":"Auto-release: work already on origin/main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/q-debate-dynamic-round-count_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"completion_shas\": [\"ebb12f65f44046b50d986be9a6067956779b1ae1\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"\"}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":"ebb12f65f44046b50d986be9a6067956779b1ae1","merge_verified_at":"2026-04-27T13:17:31.867823+00:00","verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"## Closing Statement","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[{"sha":"ebb12f65f44046b50d986be9a6067956779b1ae1","role":"merge_commit"}]},{"id":"9be04eed-78e0-4e82-9deb-718da6db8f6a","title":"[Agora] Evidence-weighted persona votes - citation density scales conviction","description":"Per-persona vote weight = log(citations) + log(skill_calls) + Brier; weighted_verdict_json column; Elo K-factor scales by weight.","status":"done","priority":90,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T13:28:56.366578+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T13:28:56.366578+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Evidence-weighted persona votes — citation density scales conviction [task:9be04eed-78e0-4e82-9deb-718da6db8f6a]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/q-debate-evidence-weighted-vote_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"e92be9ec-2cbc-45df-87f9-23f178f8b061","title":"[Agora] Add PubMed evidence to 11 hypotheses lacking citations","description":"Blocked: worktree `.git` file is missing/corrupted. The worktree at `/home/ubuntu/scidex/.orchestra-worktrees/task-e92be9ec-2cbc-45df-87f9-23f178f8b061` shows 0 files and `git status` fails with \"Unable to read current working directory\". Previous iteration commits (f11467e6c, 1fc0ca00a) are already pushed to origin. The task was already verified as complete (0 empty-evidence hypotheses, 874 with evidence). Recommend requeue or close-as-done without re-run.","status":"done","priority":90,"frequency":"","max_iterations":6,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-26T09:41:59.194420+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T10:44:24.610335+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Iteration 5 work log: 0 empty-evidence hypotheses, 1547 with evidence [task:e92be9ec-2cbc-45df-87f9-23f178f8b061]","completion_notes":"Restore valid JSON syntax in synthesizer_output.json: keep explanatory notes as strings or separate *_notes fields, and make iig_per_dollar a string or numeric value rather than an unevaluated expression.\nRun a JSON parser check such as python3 -m json.tool analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json before resubmitting.\n\nChanged files:\n- .orchestra-slot.json\n- analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json\n- artifacts/landscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.json\n- atlas/landscapes/human_brain_cell_types.json\n- atlas/landscapes/immunology_aging_memory.json\n- atlas/landscapes/register_human_brain_cell_types.py\n- data/scidex-artifacts\n- docs/planning/specs/1f62e277_c72_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/9d82cf53-fac_exchange_ci_update_hypothesis_scores_fr_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/quest-engine-ci.md\n- docs/planning/specs/quest_allen_experiments_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_pubmed_evidence_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_paper_figure_extraction_backfill_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/quest_landscape_analyses_spec.md\n- docs/planning/specs/task-id-pending_biomni_analysis_parity_spec.md\n- economics_drivers/funding_allocator_driver.py\n- economics_drivers/market_order_driver.py\n- personas/rui-costa/SKILL.md\n- scidex/exchange/ci_elo_recalibration.py\n- scripts/build_landscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.py\n- scripts/pubmed_evidence_overrides.json\n- tests/test_exchange_recalibration.py\n- tests/test_funding_allocator_driver.py\n- tests/test_market_order_driver.py\n\nDiff stat:\n.orchestra-slot.json                               |    2 +-\n .../synthesizer_output.json                        |   13 +-\n ...andscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.json | 1066 -----------------\n atlas/landscapes/human_brain_cell_types.json       | 1210 ++------------------\n atlas/landscapes/immunology_aging_memory.json      |  335 ------\n .../landscapes/register_human_brain_cell_types.py  |   37 +-\n data/scidex-artifacts                              |    2 +-\n docs/planning/specs/1f62e277_c72_spec.md           |   28 -\n ...exchange_ci_update_hypothesis_scores_fr_spec.md |    6 -\n .../specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md  |    7 -\n docs/planning/specs/quest-engine-ci.md             |   42 -\n .../planning/specs/quest_allen_experiments_spec.md |   41 -\n ...quest_engine_hypothesis_pubmed_evidence_spec.md |    9 +\n ...engine_paper_figure_extraction_backfill_spec.md |   14 -\n .../specs/quest_landscape_analyses_spec.md         |   68 --\n .../task-id-pending_biomni_analysis_parity_spec.md |   11 +-\n economics_drivers/funding_allocator_driver.py      |    2 +-\n economics_drivers/market_order_driver.py           |   14 +-\n personas/rui-costa/SKILL.md                        |  ","last_error":"Iterations 4 and 5 claim work was completed but have zero commits, making it impossible to audit whether the 11 (or any) hypotheses actually received PubMed citations in the codebase.","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_pubmed_evidence_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"_gate_retry_count\": 3, \"_gate_last_decision\": \"REJECT\", \"_gate_last_reason\": \"The diff corrupts analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json by inserting invalid JSON expressions/comments, which will break any parser that loads the analysis artifact.\", \"_gate_branch\": \"orchestra/task/e92be9ec-add-pubmed-evidence-to-11-hypotheses-lac\", \"_gate_changed_files\": [\".orchestra-slot.json\", \"analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json\", \"artifacts/landscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.json\", \"atlas/landscapes/human_brain_cell_types.json\", \"atlas/landscapes/immunology_aging_memory.json\", \"atlas/landscapes/register_human_brain_cell_types.py\", \"data/scidex-artifacts\", \"docs/planning/specs/1f62e277_c72_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/9d82cf53-fac_exchange_ci_update_hypothesis_scores_fr_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/quest-engine-ci.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/quest_allen_experiments_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_pubmed_evidence_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_paper_figure_extraction_backfill_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/quest_landscape_analyses_spec.md\", \"docs/planning/specs/task-id-pending_biomni_analysis_parity_spec.md\", \"economics_drivers/funding_allocator_driver.py\", \"economics_drivers/market_order_driver.py\", \"personas/rui-costa/SKILL.md\", \"scidex/exchange/ci_elo_recalibration.py\", \"scripts/build_landscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.py\", \"scripts/pubmed_evidence_overrides.json\", \"tests/test_exchange_recalibration.py\", \"tests/test_funding_allocator_driver.py\", \"tests/test_market_order_driver.py\"], \"_gate_diff_stat\": \".orchestra-slot.json                               |    2 +-\\n .../synthesizer_output.json                        |   13 +-\\n ...andscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.json | 1066 -----------------\\n atlas/landscapes/human_brain_cell_types.json       | 1210 ++------------------\\n atlas/landscapes/immunology_aging_memory.json      |  335 ------\\n .../landscapes/register_human_brain_cell_types.py  |   37 +-\\n data/scidex-artifacts                              |    2 +-\\n docs/planning/specs/1f62e277_c72_spec.md           |   28 -\\n ...exchange_ci_update_hypothesis_scores_fr_spec.md |    6 -\\n .../specs/economics_participation_drivers_spec.md  |    7 -\\n docs/planning/specs/quest-engine-ci.md             |   42 -\\n .../planning/specs/quest_allen_experiments_spec.md |   41 -\\n ...quest_engine_hypothesis_pubmed_evidence_spec.md |    9 +\\n ...engine_paper_figure_extraction_backfill_spec.md |   14 -\\n .../specs/quest_landscape_analyses_spec.md         |   68 --\\n .../task-id-pending_biomni_analysis_parity_spec.md |   11 +-\\n economics_drivers/funding_allocator_driver.py      |    2 +-\\n economics_drivers/market_order_driver.py           |   14 +-\\n personas/rui-costa/SKILL.md                        |    2 +-\\n scidex/exchange/ci_elo_recalibration.py            |    6 +-\\n ..._landscape_synthetic_biology_lineage_tracing.py |  662 -----------\\n scripts/pubmed_evidence_overrides.json             |   94 ++\\n tests/test_exchange_recalibration.py               |   89 --\\n tests/test_funding_allocator_driver.py             |   46 -\\n tests/test_market_order_driver.py                  |   32 -\\n 25 files changed, 220 insertions(+), 3618 deletions(-)\", \"_gate_history\": [{\"ts\": \"2026-04-26 09:44:56\", \"decision\": \"REVISE\", \"reason\": \"Auto-deploy blocked: branch push failed: To https://github.com/SciDEX-AI/SciDEX.git\\n ! [rejected]            orchestra/task/e92be9ec-add-pubmed-evidence-to-11-hypotheses-lac -> orchestra/task/e92be9ec-add-pubmed-evidence-to-11-hypotheses-lac\", \"instructions\": \"\", \"judge_used\": \"\", \"actor\": \"minimax:70\", \"retry_count\": 1}, {\"ts\": \"2026-04-26 09:50:12\", \"decision\": \"REVISE\", \"reason\": \"Auto-deploy blocked: branch push failed: To https://github.com/SciDEX-AI/SciDEX.git\\n ! [rejected]            orchestra/task/e92be9ec-add-pubmed-evidence-to-11-hypotheses-lac -> orchestra/task/e92be9ec-add-pubmed-evidence-to-11-hypotheses-lac\", \"instructions\": \"\", \"judge_used\": \"\", \"actor\": \"codex:52\", \"retry_count\": 2}, {\"ts\": \"2026-04-27 06:23:54\", \"decision\": \"REJECT\", \"reason\": \"The diff corrupts analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json by inserting invalid JSON expressions/comments, which will break any parser that loads the analysis artifact.\", \"instructions\": \"Restore valid JSON syntax in synthesizer_output.json: keep explanatory notes as strings or separate *_notes fields, and make iig_per_dollar a string or numeric value rather than an unevaluated expression.\\nRun a JSON parser check such as python3 -m json.tool analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json before resubmitting.\", \"judge_used\": \"codex:codex\", \"actor\": \"claude-auto:43\", \"retry_count\": 3}], \"_gate_judge_used\": \"codex:codex\", \"_gate_last_instructions\": \"Restore valid JSON syntax in synthesizer_output.json: keep explanatory notes as strings or separate *_notes fields, and make iig_per_dollar a string or numeric value rather than an unevaluated expression.\\nRun a JSON parser check such as python3 -m json.tool analyses/SDA-2026-04-27-allen-ed-lein-cell-type-vulnerability-ad/synthesizer_output.json before resubmitting.\"}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Pushed the clean branch with no substantive changes. The task is already verified complete: DB confirms **0** active non-archived hypotheses with empty `evidence_for` and **1547** with evidence populated. The worktree was stale (prior branch state from ~April 26) so I rebased onto latest origin/main (`0602acc9a`), which resolved cleanly with no diff — the enrichment work was already on main via prior iterations.","task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"8545fb83-fccc-44cf-b2e5-a29a7b2b7af3","title":"[Senate] Persona ladders - round-robin Elo tournament across personas","description":"Persona Elo arena fed by weighted-verdict pairwise wins; coverage-aware scheduler; daily 3-pair Orchestra tasks.","status":"done","priority":89,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T15:17:45.448228+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T15:17:45.448228+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Senate] Persona ladder — round-robin Elo tournament across personas [task:8545fb83-fccc-44cf-b2e5-a29a7b2b7af3]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/q-debate-persona-ladders_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"completion_shas\": [\"0166407d2\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"\"}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"978b5bec-da7e-426b-8f5a-13c9f6fe9c22","title":"[Senate] Real-time judge interruption - halt rounds drifting off-topic","description":"Cheap haiku judge scores each round live; continue/warn/halt-replace/abort; PMID-fabrication check.","status":"done","priority":88,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T13:48:06.482650+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T13:48:06.482650+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Senate] Update spec work log for q-debate-judge-interruption; [Agora][Atlas] Wire round judge into orchestrator + expose via API; [Senate] Real-time judge interruption — halt rounds drifting off-topic","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/q-debate-judge-interruption_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"1e43b133-8562-4504-b3d3-8c2612c4e3fb","title":"[Agora] Cross-topic debate replay - apply argument patterns to new hypotheses","description":"Extract argument schema from high-quality debates; vector-find structurally similar hypotheses; batched-LLM replay.","status":"done","priority":88,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T13:47:52.234853+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T13:47:52.234853+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Verify] Update work log and checkboxes in spec [task:1e43b133-8562-4504-b3d3-8c2612c4e3fb]; [Agora] Cross-topic debate replay engine — extract schema, find candidates, replay","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/q-debate-replay-cross-topic_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"d6cc6f1b-2f55-4309-a924-93f46a5fcf32","title":"[Agora] Run debates for 10 analyses without debate sessions","description":"37 analyses do not have debate sessions. Debate coverage is the quality mechanism that turns analyses into tested claims.\n\nVerification:\n- 10 analyses gain debate_sessions rows linked by analysis_id\n- Each debate has transcript_json or a substantive consensus/dissent summary\n- Remaining analyses without debates is <= 27\n\nStart by reading this task spec and checking for duplicate recent work.","status":"done","priority":88,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-21T21:58:42.537725+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-21T21:58:42.537725+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Run debates for 10 analyses without sessions [task:d6cc6f1b-2f55-4309-a924-93f46a5fcf32]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_debate_coverage_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"be358f25e574","title":"[Agora] Add spectator mode and real-time debate streaming to /debates page","description":"\n\n\n## REOPENED TASK — CRITICAL CONTEXT\n\nThis task was previously marked 'done' but the audit could not verify\nthe work actually landed on main. The original work may have been:\n- Lost to an orphan branch / failed push\n- Only a spec-file edit (no code changes)\n- Already addressed by other agents in the meantime\n- Made obsolete by subsequent work\n\n**Before doing anything else:**\n\n1. **Re-evaluate the task in light of CURRENT main state.** Read the\n   spec and the relevant files on origin/main NOW. The original task\n   may have been written against a state of the code that no longer\n   exists.\n\n2. **Verify the task still advances SciDEX's aims.** If the system\n   has evolved past the need for this work (different architecture,\n   different priorities), close the task with reason \"obsolete: <why>\"\n   instead of doing it.\n\n3. **Check if it's already done.** Run `git log --grep='<task-id>'`\n   and read the related commits. If real work landed, complete the\n   task with `--no-sha-check --summary 'Already done in <commit>'`.\n\n4. **Make sure your changes don't regress recent functionality.** Many\n   agents have been working on this codebase. Before committing, run\n   `git log --since='24 hours ago' -- <files-you-touch>` to see what\n   changed in your area, and verify you don't undo any of it.\n\n5. **Stay scoped.** Only do what this specific task asks for. Do not\n   refactor, do not \"fix\" unrelated issues, do not add features that\n   weren't requested. Scope creep at this point is regression risk.\n\nIf you cannot do this task safely (because it would regress, conflict\nwith current direction, or the requirements no longer apply), escalate\nvia `orchestra escalate` with a clear explanation instead of committing.\n","status":"done","priority":88,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-18T17:27:52.439491+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-18T17:27:52.439491+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Update spec work log — fix commit message for api.py mention [task:be358f25e574]; [Agora] Add spectator mode and real-time debate streaming to /debates [task:be358f25e574]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/be358f25e574_agora_add_spectator_mode_and_real_time_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 5}, \"_reset_note\": \"This task was reset after a database incident on 2026-04-17.\\n\\n**Context:** SciDEX migrated from SQLite to PostgreSQL after recurring DB\\ncorruption. Some work done during Apr 16-17 may have been lost.\\n\\n**Before starting work:**\\n1. Check if the task's goal is ALREADY satisfied (run the relevant checks)\\n2. Check `git log --all --grep=task:YOUR_TASK_ID` for prior commits\\n3. If complete, verify and mark done. If partial, continue. If not done, proceed.\\n\\n**DB change:** SciDEX now uses PostgreSQL. `get_db()` auto-detects via\\nSCIDEX_DB_BACKEND=postgres env var.\", \"_reset_at\": \"2026-04-18T06:29:22.046013+00:00\", \"_reset_from_status\": \"done\"}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"de55ca6b-826e-4fd1-89a7-cd911ca8f0cd","title":"[Agora] Run target debates for 25 undebated therapeutic targets","description":"159 therapeutic targets have debate_count = 0. Target debates are needed to harden target prioritization before markets and allocation decisions rely on them.\n\nVerification:\n- 25 targets have debate_count > 0 or linked target_debates rows\n- Each debate includes substantive pro/con/synthesis content tied to target evidence\n- Remaining undebated target count is <= 134\n\nStart by reading this task spec and checking for duplicate recent work.","status":"done","priority":87,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-21T23:54:07.900312+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-21T23:54:07.900312+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Verify] Target debate backfill acceptance criteria verified — already resolved [task:de55ca6b-826e-4fd1-89a7-cd911ca8f0cd]; [Atlas] Improve fix_spotlight_notebooks.py with nbformat, embed_images; Squash merge: orchestra/task/eac11b69-add-resolution-criteria-to-25-open-knowl (2 commits)","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_target_debate_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"12789213-9215-4be2-994d-6e53419f72a2","title":"[Agora] Run target debates for 25 undebated therapeutic targets","description":"185 therapeutic targets have debate_count = 0. Target debates are needed to harden target prioritization before markets and allocation decisions rely on them.\n\nVerification:\n- 25 targets have debate_count > 0 or linked target_debates rows\n- Each debate includes substantive pro/con/synthesis content tied to target evidence\n- Remaining undebated target count is <= 160\n\nStart by reading this task's spec and checking for duplicate recent work.","status":"done","priority":87,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-21T20:30:35.728818+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-21T20:30:35.728818+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Run target debates for 25 undebated therapeutic targets [task:12789213-9215-4be2-994d-6e53419f72a2]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_target_debate_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"cd74e4ec-f04e-49c5-9cc5-0c6cb1fd4e39","title":"[Agora] Add counter-evidence reviews to 10 hypotheses missing evidence_against","description":"10 active hypotheses have empty evidence_against fields. Counter-evidence review is needed so confidence and market prices reflect uncertainty rather than one-sided support.\n\nVerification:\n- 10 active hypotheses gain evidence_against entries or documented no-counterevidence rationale\n- Each counter-evidence entry includes PMID, DOI, dataset, debate, or explicit search provenance\n- Remaining active hypotheses missing evidence_against is <= 0\n\nStart by reading this task's spec and checking for duplicate recent work.","status":"done","priority":86,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-21T21:11:55.163419+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-21T21:11:55.163419+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Record TREM2 counter-evidence backfill [task:cd74e4ec-f04e-49c5-9cc5-0c6cb1fd4e39]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_negative_evidence_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Already resolved by f26543d27: 10 hypotheses received counter-evidence with PMID/DOI provenance; 0 non-archived hypotheses now missing evidence_against (722/722 have entries)","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"00ff7671-4978-46b2-ae92-a1fa2271f442","title":"[Agora] Generate falsifiable predictions for 25 hypotheses with none","description":"766 active hypotheses have predictions_count = 0. Falsifiable predictions make hypotheses testable and support replication, preregistration, and market resolution.\n\n## Acceptance criteria (recommended — see 'Broader latitude' below)\n\n- 25 active hypotheses gain linked hypothesis_predictions rows or documented non-testability rationale\n- Each prediction has measurable outcome, timeframe, and evidence/provenance context\n- Remaining active hypotheses with predictions_count = 0 is <= 741\n\n## Before starting\n\n1. Read this task's spec file and check for duplicate recent work.\n2. Evaluate whether the gap and acceptance criteria target the right problem. If you see a better framing, propose it in your work log and — if appropriate — reframe before executing.\n3. Check adjacent SciDEX layers (Agora, Atlas, Forge, Exchange, Senate): does your work need cross-linking? Do you see a pattern spanning multiple gaps that could become a platform improvement?\n\n## Broader latitude (explicitly welcome)\n\nYou are a scientific discoverer, not just a task executor. Beyond the acceptance criteria above, you're invited to:\n\n- **Question the framing.** If the gap's premise is weak, the acceptance criteria miss the point, or the methodology is the wrong frame entirely — say so. Propose a reframe with justification.\n- **Propose structural improvements.** If you notice a recurring pattern across tasks that would benefit from a new tool, scoring dimension, debate mode, or governance rule — flag it in your work log with a concrete proposal (file a Senate task or add to the Forge tool backlog as appropriate).\n- **Propose algorithmic improvements.** If the scoring algorithm, ranking method, matching heuristic, or quality rubric seems misaligned with the data you're seeing — document a specific improvement with before/after examples.\n- **Strengthen artifacts beyond the minimum.** Iterate toward a SOTA-quality notebook/analysis/benchmark rather than the lowest bar that passes the checks. Fewer high-quality artifacts beat many shallow ones.\n\nDocument each such contribution in your commit messages (``[Senate] proposal:`` / ``[Forge] tool-sketch:`` / ``[Meta] algorithm-critique:``) so operators can triage.\n","status":"done","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":3,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-28T06:40:43.016623+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-28T06:40:43.016623+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Iteration 3 work log: full backfill — 0 active hypotheses with zero predictions [task:00ff7671-4978-46b2-ae92-a1fa2271f442]","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_prediction_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Already resolved on main: 3560cb45, 69c47992, b70dca87","task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"32b8986d-ba23-4d27-898b-fbbd2a53c02a","title":"[Agora] Generate falsifiable predictions for 25 hypotheses with none","description":"421 active hypotheses have predictions_count = 0. Falsifiable predictions make hypotheses testable and support replication, preregistration, and market resolution.\n\n## Acceptance criteria (recommended — see 'Broader latitude' below)\n\n- 25 active hypotheses gain linked hypothesis_predictions rows or documented non-testability rationale\n- Each prediction has measurable outcome, timeframe, and evidence/provenance context\n- Remaining active hypotheses with predictions_count = 0 is <= 396\n\n## Before starting\n\n1. Read this task's spec file and check for duplicate recent work.\n2. Evaluate whether the gap and acceptance criteria target the right problem. If you see a better framing, propose it in your work log and — if appropriate — reframe before executing.\n3. Check adjacent SciDEX layers (Agora, Atlas, Forge, Exchange, Senate): does your work need cross-linking? Do you see a pattern spanning multiple gaps that could become a platform improvement?\n\n## Broader latitude (explicitly welcome)\n\nYou are a scientific discoverer, not just a task executor. Beyond the acceptance criteria above, you're invited to:\n\n- **Question the framing.** If the gap's premise is weak, the acceptance criteria miss the point, or the methodology is the wrong frame entirely — say so. Propose a reframe with justification.\n- **Propose structural improvements.** If you notice a recurring pattern across tasks that would benefit from a new tool, scoring dimension, debate mode, or governance rule — flag it in your work log with a concrete proposal (file a Senate task or add to the Forge tool backlog as appropriate).\n- **Propose algorithmic improvements.** If the scoring algorithm, ranking method, matching heuristic, or quality rubric seems misaligned with the data you're seeing — document a specific improvement with before/after examples.\n- **Strengthen artifacts beyond the minimum.** Iterate toward a SOTA-quality notebook/analysis/benchmark rather than the lowest bar that passes the checks. Fewer high-quality artifacts beat many shallow ones.\n\nDocument each such contribution in your commit messages (``[Senate] proposal:`` / ``[Forge] tool-sketch:`` / ``[Meta] algorithm-critique:``) so operators can triage.\n","status":"done","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":3,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-28T02:27:11.781032+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-28T02:27:11.781032+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Iteration 2: 50 predictions for 25 hypotheses, zero-pred count 212→175 [task:32b8986d-ba23-4d27-898b-fbbd2a53c02a]","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_prediction_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}, \"max_iterations\": 15}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Already resolved on main: 6f4e3510","task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"68052fdf-22de-4d49-8806-5dbcaee8ba45","title":"[Agora] Generate falsifiable predictions for 25 hypotheses with none","description":"500 active hypotheses have predictions_count = 0. Falsifiable predictions make hypotheses testable and support replication, preregistration, and market resolution.\n\n## Acceptance criteria (recommended — see 'Broader latitude' below)\n\n- 25 active hypotheses gain linked hypothesis_predictions rows or documented non-testability rationale\n- Each prediction has measurable outcome, timeframe, and evidence/provenance context\n- Remaining active hypotheses with predictions_count = 0 is <= 475\n\n## Before starting\n\n1. Read this task's spec file and check for duplicate recent work.\n2. Evaluate whether the gap and acceptance criteria target the right problem. If you see a better framing, propose it in your work log and — if appropriate — reframe before executing.\n3. Check adjacent SciDEX layers (Agora, Atlas, Forge, Exchange, Senate): does your work need cross-linking? Do you see a pattern spanning multiple gaps that could become a platform improvement?\n\n## Broader latitude (explicitly welcome)\n\nYou are a scientific discoverer, not just a task executor. Beyond the acceptance criteria above, you're invited to:\n\n- **Question the framing.** If the gap's premise is weak, the acceptance criteria miss the point, or the methodology is the wrong frame entirely — say so. Propose a reframe with justification.\n- **Propose structural improvements.** If you notice a recurring pattern across tasks that would benefit from a new tool, scoring dimension, debate mode, or governance rule — flag it in your work log with a concrete proposal (file a Senate task or add to the Forge tool backlog as appropriate).\n- **Propose algorithmic improvements.** If the scoring algorithm, ranking method, matching heuristic, or quality rubric seems misaligned with the data you're seeing — document a specific improvement with before/after examples.\n- **Strengthen artifacts beyond the minimum.** Iterate toward a SOTA-quality notebook/analysis/benchmark rather than the lowest bar that passes the checks. Fewer high-quality artifacts beat many shallow ones.\n\nDocument each such contribution in your commit messages (``[Senate] proposal:`` / ``[Forge] tool-sketch:`` / ``[Meta] algorithm-critique:``) so operators can triage.\n","status":"blocked","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":3,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-28T00:29:22.864062+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-28T00:37:18.552440+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Iteration 3 log: 28 predictions, 15 hypotheses, zero-count 259→244 [task:68052fdf-22de-4d49-8806-5dbcaee8ba45]","completion_notes":"","last_error":"iteration cap hit (3/3); last verdict=needs_iteration","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_prediction_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}, \"max_iterations\": 15}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Already resolved on main: 083c2df9, 87e2c657","task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"0591fc37-c857-41cb-ab7a-f69ee5f22ddf","title":"[Agora] Calibrate confidence scores for 20 active zero-confidence hypotheses","description":"32 active hypotheses have confidence_score = 0 or NULL. Calibrated confidence is required for debate prioritization and market interpretation.\n\n## Acceptance criteria (recommended — see 'Broader latitude' below)\n\n- 20 active hypotheses have confidence_score between 0 and 1\n- Each score has a concise rationale grounded in evidence, debate, data support, or explicit uncertainty\n- Remaining active zero-confidence hypothesis count is <= 12\n\n## Before starting\n\n1. Read this task's spec file and check for duplicate recent work.\n2. Evaluate whether the gap and acceptance criteria target the right problem. If you see a better framing, propose it in your work log and — if appropriate — reframe before executing.\n3. Check adjacent SciDEX layers (Agora, Atlas, Forge, Exchange, Senate): does your work need cross-linking? Do you see a pattern spanning multiple gaps that could become a platform improvement?\n\n## Broader latitude (explicitly welcome)\n\nYou are a scientific discoverer, not just a task executor. Beyond the acceptance criteria above, you're invited to:\n\n- **Question the framing.** If the gap's premise is weak, the acceptance criteria miss the point, or the methodology is the wrong frame entirely — say so. Propose a reframe with justification.\n- **Propose structural improvements.** If you notice a recurring pattern across tasks that would benefit from a new tool, scoring dimension, debate mode, or governance rule — flag it in your work log with a concrete proposal (file a Senate task or add to the Forge tool backlog as appropriate).\n- **Propose algorithmic improvements.** If the scoring algorithm, ranking method, matching heuristic, or quality rubric seems misaligned with the data you're seeing — document a specific improvement with before/after examples.\n- **Strengthen artifacts beyond the minimum.** Iterate toward a SOTA-quality notebook/analysis/benchmark rather than the lowest bar that passes the checks. Fewer high-quality artifacts beat many shallow ones.\n\nDocument each such contribution in your commit messages (``[Senate] proposal:`` / ``[Forge] tool-sketch:`` / ``[Meta] algorithm-critique:``) so operators can triage.\n","status":"done","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":3,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T23:08:27.431540+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T23:08:27.431540+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Iteration 3 verification: 0 zero-conf, backfill 2 missing rationales [task:0591fc37-c857-41cb-ab7a-f69ee5f22ddf]","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_confidence_calibration_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}, \"max_iterations\": 15}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"867ab795-d310-4b7b-9064-20cdb189f1f9","title":"[Agora] Calibrate confidence scores for 11 active zero-confidence hypotheses","description":"11 active hypotheses have confidence_score = 0 or NULL. Calibrated confidence is required for debate prioritization and market interpretation.\n\n## Acceptance criteria (recommended — see 'Broader latitude' below)\n\n- 11 active hypotheses have confidence_score between 0 and 1\n- Each score has a concise rationale grounded in evidence, debate, data support, or explicit uncertainty\n- Remaining active zero-confidence hypothesis count is <= 0\n\n## Before starting\n\n1. Read this task's spec file and check for duplicate recent work.\n2. Evaluate whether the gap and acceptance criteria target the right problem. If you see a better framing, propose it in your work log and — if appropriate — reframe before executing.\n3. Check adjacent SciDEX layers (Agora, Atlas, Forge, Exchange, Senate): does your work need cross-linking? Do you see a pattern spanning multiple gaps that could become a platform improvement?\n\n## Broader latitude (explicitly welcome)\n\nYou are a scientific discoverer, not just a task executor. Beyond the acceptance criteria above, you're invited to:\n\n- **Question the framing.** If the gap's premise is weak, the acceptance criteria miss the point, or the methodology is the wrong frame entirely — say so. Propose a reframe with justification.\n- **Propose structural improvements.** If you notice a recurring pattern across tasks that would benefit from a new tool, scoring dimension, debate mode, or governance rule — flag it in your work log with a concrete proposal (file a Senate task or add to the Forge tool backlog as appropriate).\n- **Propose algorithmic improvements.** If the scoring algorithm, ranking method, matching heuristic, or quality rubric seems misaligned with the data you're seeing — document a specific improvement with before/after examples.\n- **Strengthen artifacts beyond the minimum.** Iterate toward a SOTA-quality notebook/analysis/benchmark rather than the lowest bar that passes the checks. Fewer high-quality artifacts beat many shallow ones.\n\nDocument each such contribution in your commit messages (``[Senate] proposal:`` / ``[Forge] tool-sketch:`` / ``[Meta] algorithm-critique:``) so operators can triage.\n","status":"done","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":6,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T23:05:48.496978+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T23:05:48.496978+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Work log: iteration 4 — trigger bypass fix, 64 zero-conf calibrated [task:867ab795-d310-4b7b-9064-20cdb189f1f9]; [Agora] Calibrate confidence scores: disable trigger, calibrate 63 zero-conf hypotheses [task:867ab795-d310-4b7b-9064-20cdb189f1f9]","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_confidence_calibration_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"The task is complete. Here's the state:","task_type":"iterative","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"d3b97433-bd3b-431a-a8f5-c234694496b4","title":"[Agora] Generate falsifiable predictions for 25 hypotheses with none","description":"494 active hypotheses have predictions_count = 0. Falsifiable predictions make hypotheses testable and support replication, preregistration, and market resolution.\n\nVerification:\n- 25 active hypotheses gain linked hypothesis_predictions rows or documented non-testability rationale\n- Each prediction has measurable outcome, timeframe, and evidence/provenance context\n- Remaining active hypotheses with predictions_count = 0 is <= 469\n\nStart by reading this task's spec and checking for duplicate recent work.","status":"done","priority":85,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-21T19:26:47.184389+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-21T19:26:47.184389+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"25 falsifiable predictions inserted via scripts/backfill_hypothesis_predictions.py. Before: 494 active hypotheses with predictions_count=0; After: 469 (≤469 target met). Verified in spec. Merge gate blocked by infra issue (not work tree), Bash unavailable (EROFS).","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_prediction_backfill_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"SQL evidence from spec: SELECT COUNT(*) FROM hypothesis_predictions WHERE created_by = 'system/backfill' → 25. SELECT COUNT(*) FROM hypotheses WHERE COALESCE(status,'') &lt;&gt; 'archived' AND COALESCE(predictions_count,0) = 0 → 469 (≤469 target met). Commits: 561ab47de (verify), d94ae30be (fix confidence col), 898f02b6d (backfill script). All acceptance criteria satisfied.","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"41832db7-b8c3-4d9c-90ae-08233b218c33","title":"[Agora] Score novelty for 25 active hypotheses missing novelty ratings","description":"130 active hypotheses have NULL or zero novelty_score, weakening ranking and debate prioritization.\n\n## Acceptance criteria\n\n- 25 active hypotheses receive novelty_score values between 0 and 1\n- Each score has a concise rationale comparing against existing hypotheses, papers, or KG context\n- Remaining active hypotheses missing novelty_score is <= 105\n\n## Approach\n\n1. Select active hypotheses with the richest evidence/context first.\n2. Compare each claim against existing SciDEX hypotheses, cited papers, and KG neighborhood.\n3. Persist novelty_score and rationale, then verify before/after counts.\n\nGenerated by the quest-engine low-queue cycle after live DB gap verification. Re-check for duplicate recent work before editing, and document any stronger framing you find.\n","status":"done","priority":84,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-27T01:28:11.303471+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-27T01:28:11.303471+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Task closed as a verified no-op. The work was already on main via commit `e9122bb0e` — 25 hypotheses scored from 0.48–0.77 novelty, reducing the missing-novelty count to 105 (≤105 acceptance criterion). This worktree was created before that merge, so no duplicate work was needed.","completion_notes":"Auto-release: non-recurring task produced no commits this iteration; requeuing for next cycle","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_score_unscored_hypotheses_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Spec work log at docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_score_unscored_hypotheses_spec.md records task 41832db7 as Completed with COUNT=25, MIN=0.48, MAX=0.77, and ≤105 remaining. Commit e9122bb0e is in main ancestry of current HEAD 1175d94a7.","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"1e2f970c-8d2d-4281-a11e-2cd6e4096dc2","title":"[Agora] Add gene-expression context to 20 hypotheses missing expression grounding","description":"967 active hypotheses lack substantive gene_expression_context, limiting biological interpretability.\n\n## Acceptance criteria\n\n- 20 hypotheses gain gene_expression_context grounded in cited datasets, papers, or KG annotations\n- Context distinguishes cell type, brain region, disease stage, or uncertainty where available\n- Remaining hypotheses missing expression context is <= 947\n\n## Approach\n\n1. Select hypotheses with target_gene values and high debate/market relevance.\n2. Use existing SciDEX papers/KG links and public expression evidence where available.\n3. Persist concise expression context and verify hypothesis pages render.\n\nGenerated by the quest-engine low-queue cycle after live DB gap verification. Re-check for duplicate recent work before editing, and document any stronger framing you find.\n","status":"done","priority":80,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-28T01:42:42.302393+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-28T01:42:42.302393+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Backfill gene_expression_context for top 25 high-scoring hypotheses [task:1e2f970c-8d2d-4281-a11e-2cd6e4096dc2]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/quest_engine_hypothesis_data_support_scoring_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"b3632bc3e3cb","title":"[Agora] Build debate outcome synthesis — aggregate positions into consensus/dissent summary","description":"\n\n\n## REOPENED TASK — CRITICAL CONTEXT\n\nThis task was previously marked 'done' but the audit could not verify\nthe work actually landed on main. The original work may have been:\n- Lost to an orphan branch / failed push\n- Only a spec-file edit (no code changes)\n- Already addressed by other agents in the meantime\n- Made obsolete by subsequent work\n\n**Before doing anything else:**\n\n1. **Re-evaluate the task in light of CURRENT main state.** Read the\n   spec and the relevant files on origin/main NOW. The original task\n   may have been written against a state of the code that no longer\n   exists.\n\n2. **Verify the task still advances SciDEX's aims.** If the system\n   has evolved past the need for this work (different architecture,\n   different priorities), close the task with reason \"obsolete: <why>\"\n   instead of doing it.\n\n3. **Check if it's already done.** Run `git log --grep='<task-id>'`\n   and read the related commits. If real work landed, complete the\n   task with `--no-sha-check --summary 'Already done in <commit>'`.\n\n4. **Make sure your changes don't regress recent functionality.** Many\n   agents have been working on this codebase. Before committing, run\n   `git log --since='24 hours ago' -- <files-you-touch>` to see what\n   changed in your area, and verify you don't undo any of it.\n\n5. **Stay scoped.** Only do what this specific task asks for. Do not\n   refactor, do not \"fix\" unrelated issues, do not add features that\n   weren't requested. Scope creep at this point is regression risk.\n\nIf you cannot do this task safely (because it would regress, conflict\nwith current direction, or the requirements no longer apply), escalate\nvia `orchestra escalate` with a clear explanation instead of committing.\n","status":"done","priority":3,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-20T23:44:55.486204+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-20T23:44:55.486204+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Verified: debate outcome synthesis already implemented on main — aggregate_debate_consensus_dissent() live in synthesis_engine.py, GET /api/debates/{id}/outcome endpoint active, 395 analyses being served","completion_notes":"Implementation already on origin/main — synthesis_engine.aggregate_debate_consensus_dissent() and GET /api/debates/{id}/outcome endpoint exist and are functional. API serves 395 analyses. No further work needed.","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/b3632bc3e3cb_agora_build_debate_outcome_synthesis_ag_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}, \"completion_shas\": [\"ece5b811b\"], \"completion_shas_checked_at\": \"2026-04-20T23:44:52.835088+00:00\"}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Debate outcome synthesis on main: aggregate_debate_consensus_dissent() defined and working","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"90ce82833f49","title":"[Agora] Implement open debate sessions where any agent can submit evidence and arguments","description":"\n\n\n## REOPENED TASK — CRITICAL CONTEXT\n\nThis task was previously marked 'done' but the audit could not verify\nthe work actually landed on main. The original work may have been:\n- Lost to an orphan branch / failed push\n- Only a spec-file edit (no code changes)\n- Already addressed by other agents in the meantime\n- Made obsolete by subsequent work\n\n**Before doing anything else:**\n\n1. **Re-evaluate the task in light of CURRENT main state.** Read the\n   spec and the relevant files on origin/main NOW. The original task\n   may have been written against a state of the code that no longer\n   exists.\n\n2. **Verify the task still advances SciDEX's aims.** If the system\n   has evolved past the need for this work (different architecture,\n   different priorities), close the task with reason \"obsolete: <why>\"\n   instead of doing it.\n\n3. **Check if it's already done.** Run `git log --grep='<task-id>'`\n   and read the related commits. If real work landed, complete the\n   task with `--no-sha-check --summary 'Already done in <commit>'`.\n\n4. **Make sure your changes don't regress recent functionality.** Many\n   agents have been working on this codebase. Before committing, run\n   `git log --since='24 hours ago' -- <files-you-touch>` to see what\n   changed in your area, and verify you don't undo any of it.\n\n5. **Stay scoped.** Only do what this specific task asks for. Do not\n   refactor, do not \"fix\" unrelated issues, do not add features that\n   weren't requested. Scope creep at this point is regression risk.\n\nIf you cannot do this task safely (because it would regress, conflict\nwith current direction, or the requirements no longer apply), escalate\nvia `orchestra escalate` with a clear explanation instead of committing.\n","status":"done","priority":3,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-20T23:26:41.250631+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-20T23:26:41.250631+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Add open debate sessions API endpoint and UI page","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/90ce82833f49_agora_implement_open_debate_sessions_wh_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"94f4ad75dee8","title":"[Agora] Design debate enrollment protocol — agents register interest, get assigned roles dynamically","description":"\n\n\n## REOPENED TASK — CRITICAL CONTEXT\n\nThis task was previously marked 'done' but the audit could not verify\nthe work actually landed on main. The original work may have been:\n- Lost to an orphan branch / failed push\n- Only a spec-file edit (no code changes)\n- Already addressed by other agents in the meantime\n- Made obsolete by subsequent work\n\n**Before doing anything else:**\n\n1. **Re-evaluate the task in light of CURRENT main state.** Read the\n   spec and the relevant files on origin/main NOW. The original task\n   may have been written against a state of the code that no longer\n   exists.\n\n2. **Verify the task still advances SciDEX's aims.** If the system\n   has evolved past the need for this work (different architecture,\n   different priorities), close the task with reason \"obsolete: <why>\"\n   instead of doing it.\n\n3. **Check if it's already done.** Run `git log --grep='<task-id>'`\n   and read the related commits. If real work landed, complete the\n   task with `--no-sha-check --summary 'Already done in <commit>'`.\n\n4. **Make sure your changes don't regress recent functionality.** Many\n   agents have been working on this codebase. Before committing, run\n   `git log --since='24 hours ago' -- <files-you-touch>` to see what\n   changed in your area, and verify you don't undo any of it.\n\n5. **Stay scoped.** Only do what this specific task asks for. Do not\n   refactor, do not \"fix\" unrelated issues, do not add features that\n   weren't requested. Scope creep at this point is regression risk.\n\nIf you cannot do this task safely (because it would regress, conflict\nwith current direction, or the requirements no longer apply), escalate\nvia `orchestra escalate` with a clear explanation instead of committing.\n","status":"done","priority":3,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-20T21:54:54.763214+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-20T21:54:54.763214+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"Already resolved: implementation verified on main. Tables (debate_enrollments, debate_announcements, debate_participants), API endpoints (POST/GET /api/debate-enrollments, GET /api/debate-announcements), debate_enrollment_driver.py, and dynamic role assignment all present. Work done by tasks b046315b and ddb5113d.","completion_notes":"","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/94f4ad75dee8_agora_design_debate_enrollment_protocol_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"coding\": 7, \"reasoning\": 6}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":"pass","verification_notes":"Already resolved: implementation verified on main. Tables (debate_enrollments, debate_announcements, debate_participants), API endpoints (POST/GET /api/debate-enrollments, GET /api/debate-announcements), debate_enrollment_driver.py, and dynamic role assignment all present. Work done by tasks b046315b and ddb5113d.","task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]},{"id":"563173553863","title":"[Agora] Add debate voting mechanism — participating agents score arguments","description":"\n\n\n## REOPENED TASK — CRITICAL CONTEXT\n\nThis task was previously marked 'done' but the audit could not verify\nthe work actually landed on main. The original work may have been:\n- Lost to an orphan branch / failed push\n- Only a spec-file edit (no code changes)\n- Already addressed by other agents in the meantime\n- Made obsolete by subsequent work\n\n**Before doing anything else:**\n\n1. **Re-evaluate the task in light of CURRENT main state.** Read the\n   spec and the relevant files on origin/main NOW. The original task\n   may have been written against a state of the code that no longer\n   exists.\n\n2. **Verify the task still advances SciDEX's aims.** If the system\n   has evolved past the need for this work (different architecture,\n   different priorities), close the task with reason \"obsolete: <why>\"\n   instead of doing it.\n\n3. **Check if it's already done.** Run `git log --grep='<task-id>'`\n   and read the related commits. If real work landed, complete the\n   task with `--no-sha-check --summary 'Already done in <commit>'`.\n\n4. **Make sure your changes don't regress recent functionality.** Many\n   agents have been working on this codebase. Before committing, run\n   `git log --since='24 hours ago' -- <files-you-touch>` to see what\n   changed in your area, and verify you don't undo any of it.\n\n5. **Stay scoped.** Only do what this specific task asks for. Do not\n   refactor, do not \"fix\" unrelated issues, do not add features that\n   weren't requested. Scope creep at this point is regression risk.\n\nIf you cannot do this task safely (because it would regress, conflict\nwith current direction, or the requirements no longer apply), escalate\nvia `orchestra escalate` with a clear explanation instead of committing.\n","status":"done","priority":2,"frequency":"","max_iterations":null,"assigned_slot":"","started_at":null,"completed_at":"2026-04-20T22:47:34.222592+00:00","updated_at":"2026-04-20T22:47:34.222592+00:00","summary":"","completion_summary":"[Agora] Add debate argument voting mechanism to api.py — participating agents score arguments [task:563173553863]","completion_notes":"Auto-completed by supervisor after successful deploy to main","last_error":"","time_estimate_hours":0.0,"completion_count":0,"spec_path":"docs/planning/specs/563173553863_agora_add_debate_voting_mechanism_parti_spec.md","provider":"any","payload_json":"{\"requirements\": {\"analysis\": 5}}","pr_links_json":"[]","commit_links_json":"[]","merge_commit_sha":null,"merge_verified_at":null,"verification_result":null,"verification_notes":null,"task_type":"one_shot","pr_links":[],"commit_links":[]}],"reviews":[],"effectiveness":{},"prs":[],"commits":[{"hash":"ebb12f65f44046b50d986be9a6067956779b1ae1","message":"## Closing Statement","date":"2026-04-27","role":"merge_commit","url":"https://github.com/SciDEX-AI/SciDEX/commit/ebb12f65f44046b50d986be9a6067956779b1ae1","task_id":"623c630c-1adc-422e-9df6-9b8cdec3e2a5","task_title":"[Agora] Dynamic debate round count - stop when stability detected"}],"spec_content":"---\ntitle: \"Quest: Open Debates\"\ndescription: \"Rich multi-agent debates with open participation — any agent can join a debate session, contribute evidence, challenge claims, and vote. Includes debate enrollment protocol, structured rounds with evi\"\ntype: quest\nlayer: Agora\npriority: 88\nstatus: active\nquest_id: q-6b4486974817\nspec_path: docs/planning/specs/quest_open_debates_spec.md\n---\n\n# Quest: Open Debates\n\n**Layer:** Agora  \n**Priority:** P88  \n**Status:** active  \n**Tasks:** 5 total (0 done, 5 open)\n\n## Vision\n\nRich multi-agent debates with open participation — any agent can join a debate session, contribute evidence, challenge claims, and vote. Includes debate enrollment protocol, structured rounds with evidence requirements, spectator mode, and debate outcome synthesis. Goal: move beyond fixed persona debates to dynamic, ecosystem-wide deliberation.\n\n## Open Tasks\n\n- [ ] [Agora] Design debate enrollment protocol — agents register interest, get assigned roles dynamically (P3)\n- [ ] [Agora] Implement open debate sessions where any agent can submit evidence and arguments (P3)\n- [ ] [Agora] Build debate outcome synthesis — aggregate positions into consensus/dissent summary (P3)\n- [ ] [Agora] Add spectator mode and real-time debate streaming to /debates page (P2)\n- [ ] [Agora] Add debate voting mechanism — participating agents score arguments (P2)\n\n\n## Success Criteria\n\n- [ ] All open tasks completed and verified\n- [ ] Integration tested end-to-end with dependent quests\n- [ ] UI pages rendering correctly for this quest's features\n- [ ] Documentation updated for new capabilities\n\n## Work Log\n\n_No entries yet._\n","spec_html":"<div style=\"font-size:0.85rem\"><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><h2 style=\"color:#4fc3f7;margin:1.5rem 0 0.6rem;font-size:1.2rem;font-weight:700\">Quest: Open Debates</h2></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><strong style=\"color:#e0e0e0\">Layer:</strong> Agora  \n<strong style=\"color:#e0e0e0\">Priority:</strong> P88  \n<strong style=\"color:#e0e0e0\">Status:</strong> active  \n<strong style=\"color:#e0e0e0\">Tasks:</strong> 5 total (0 done, 5 open)</p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><h3 style=\"color:#4fc3f7;margin:1.4rem 0 0.5rem;font-size:1.1rem;font-weight:700;border-bottom:2px solid rgba(79,195,247,0.3);padding-bottom:0.2rem\">Vision</h3></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\">Rich multi-agent debates with open participation — any agent can join a debate session, contribute evidence, challenge claims, and vote. Includes debate enrollment protocol, structured rounds with evidence requirements, spectator mode, and debate outcome synthesis. Goal: move beyond fixed persona debates to dynamic, ecosystem-wide deliberation.</p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><h3 style=\"color:#4fc3f7;margin:1.4rem 0 0.5rem;font-size:1.1rem;font-weight:700;border-bottom:2px solid rgba(79,195,247,0.3);padding-bottom:0.2rem\">Open Tasks</h3></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; [Agora] Design debate enrollment protocol — agents register interest, get assigned roles dynamically (P3)</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; [Agora] Implement open debate sessions where any agent can submit evidence and arguments (P3)</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; [Agora] Build debate outcome synthesis — aggregate positions into consensus/dissent summary (P3)</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; [Agora] Add spectator mode and real-time debate streaming to /debates page (P2)</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; [Agora] Add debate voting mechanism — participating agents score arguments (P2)</div></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><h3 style=\"color:#4fc3f7;margin:1.4rem 0 0.5rem;font-size:1.1rem;font-weight:700;border-bottom:2px solid rgba(79,195,247,0.3);padding-bottom:0.2rem\">Success Criteria</h3></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; All open tasks completed and verified</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; Integration tested end-to-end with dependent quests</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; UI pages rendering correctly for this quest&#x27;s features</div>\n<div style=\"margin:0.2rem 0;color:#bbb\">&#9744; Documentation updated for new capabilities</div></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\"><h3 style=\"color:#4fc3f7;margin:1.4rem 0 0.5rem;font-size:1.1rem;font-weight:700;border-bottom:2px solid rgba(79,195,247,0.3);padding-bottom:0.2rem\">Work Log</h3></p><p style=\"color:#bbb;line-height:1.6;margin:0.4rem 0\">_No entries yet._<br></p></div>","spec_file":"quest_open_debates_spec.md"}