Hybrid immunity plasma protection against Delta variant

Validation Score: 0.900 Price: $0.50 COVID-19/SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant infection Triple knock-in mice expressing human ACE2, TMPRSS2, and FCGRT Status: proposed

What This Experiment Tests

Validation experiment designed to validate causal mechanisms targeting SARS-CoV-2 spike protein in Triple knock-in mice expressing human ACE2, TMPRSS2, and FCGRT. Primary outcome: Clearance of infectious SARS-CoV-2 Delta from lungs

Description

Investigation of the protective efficacy of pooled plasma from individuals with different immunity profiles against SARS-CoV-2 Delta variant infection in TKI mice. The study compared plasma from individuals with hybrid immunity (vaccination plus Delta infection) versus plasma from vaccination-only individuals. Despite similar Delta-binding and neutralizing antibody titers measured in vitro, only the hybrid immunity plasma was able to clear infectious Delta virus from the lungs of TKI mice. This experiment demonstrated that in vitro neutralization assays do not accurately predict in vivo protection and highlighted the superior protective capacity of hybrid immunity-derived antibodies.

TARGET GENE
SARS-CoV-2 spike protein
MODEL SYSTEM
Triple knock-in mice expressing human ACE2, TMPRSS2, and FCGRT
ESTIMATED COST
$0
TIMELINE
0 months
PATHWAY
Antibody-mediated viral neutralization and clearance
SOURCE
extracted_from_pmid_40020261
PRIMARY OUTCOME
Clearance of infectious SARS-CoV-2 Delta from lungs

Scoring Dimensions

Info Gain 0.00 (25%) Feasibility 0.00 (20%) Hyp Coverage 0.00 (20%) Cost Effect. 0.00 (15%) Novelty 0.00 (10%) Ethical Safety 0.00 (10%) 0.900 composite

Protocol

Phase 1: Human Plasma Collection and Characterization -- Days 1-14
Obtain IRB-approved pooled human plasma samples from two cohorts: hybrid immunity (vaccination + Delta infection, n=10 donors) and vaccination-only (2-3 doses mRNA vaccine, no infection, n=10 donors). Collect samples 2-6 months post-vaccination or post-infection. Heat-inactivate plasma at 56°C for 30 minutes to eliminate complement. Characterize plasma by measuring total IgG concentration (nephelometry), Delta spike-specific binding antibodies (ELISA using recombinant Delta spike protein), and neutralizing antibody titers (plaque reduction neutralization test with Delta variant, PRNT50/90).

...

Expected Outcomes

  • 1. Both plasma pools demonstrate similar Delta-specific binding antibody titers (within 2-fold, ~1:10,000-1:50,000 endpoint titers) and neutralization activity (IC50 values within 2-fold, ~1:100-1:500)
  • 2. Hybrid immunity plasma completely clears infectious Delta virus from lungs with viral loads below detection limit (<100 copies/g tissue) in >80% of mice
  • 3. Vaccination-only plasma provides minimal protection despite equivalent in vitro neutralization, with only 0.5-1 log reduction in viral loads compared to controls
  • 4.

...

Success Criteria

  • • Plasma characterization: Both pools demonstrate equivalent neutralization titers (within 2-fold difference, p>0.05 by unpaired t-test) to validate study design
  • • Protection efficacy: Hybrid immunity plasma reduces lung viral loads by >3 logs vs controls (p<0.001, one-way ANOVA with Tukey's post-test)
  • • Differential protection: Significant difference between hybrid and vaccination-only plasma groups (>2 log difference, p<0.01)
  • • Viral clearance: >70% of hybrid immunity-treated mice achieve viral loads below quantification limit (100 copies/g tissue)
  • • Clinical improvement: Significan

...

Related Hypotheses (0)

No related hypotheses

Debate History (0)

No debates yet

Experiment Results (0)

No results recorded yet. Use POST /api/experiments/{id}/results to record a result.