Comparison of free-text clinical reports vs Mini-ICF-APP structured assessment

Clinical Score: 0.900 Price: $0.50 psychiatric disorders human patients Status: proposed

What This Experiment Tests

Clinical experiment designed to assess clinical efficacy targeting N/A in human patients. Primary outcome: work ability assessment accuracy

Description

This study compared the effectiveness of traditional free-text clinical reports versus structured capacity assessments using the Mini-ICF-APP Social Functioning Scale in evaluating work ability in psychiatric patients. The investigation aimed to determine whether usual clinical judgment and structured capacity rating both support work ability decisions. Medical reports from 100 patients in a psychotherapy hospital were analyzed for psychopathological symptoms and capacity disorders using both approaches. The study found that while free-text reports mainly identified impairments in endurance, flexibility, and social contacts, the structured Mini-ICF-APP assessment captured additional capacity impairments including adherence to rules, planning and structuring, assertiveness, and group integration. The structured assessment showed higher rates of stated impairments across all capacity dimensions compared to free-text reports.

TARGET GENE
N/A
MODEL SYSTEM
human patients
ESTIMATED COST
$0
TIMELINE
0 months
PATHWAY
N/A
SOURCE
extracted_from_pmid_31578018
PRIMARY OUTCOME
work ability assessment accuracy

Scoring Dimensions

Info Gain 0.00 (25%) Feasibility 0.00 (20%) Hyp Coverage 0.00 (20%) Cost Effect. 0.00 (15%) Novelty 0.00 (10%) Ethical Safety 0.00 (10%) 0.900 composite

📖 Wiki Pages

APP ProteinproteinAPP/PS1 Dual Transgenic Mouse ModelmodelAPP/PS1 Double Transgenic Mouse ModelmechanismAPP Processing and Amyloid-Beta ProductionmechanismAPP-BACE1-Fe65 ComplexmechanismAPP Amyloid Pathway in Alzheimer's DiseasemechanismAPP→Amyloid-beta→Plaque→Alzheimer's Disease CausalpathwayAPP Gene Dosage Reduction Therapy for Down SyndromideaAPP — Amyloid Precursor ProteingeneAPP GenegeneAPP Swedish Mutation (APPswe)mutationAPP Mutations in Alzheimer's DiseasediseaseAPP Flemish Mutation (APP Flemish)diseaseAPP Dutch Mutation (APP Dutch)diseaseAPP Arctic Mutation (APP Arctic)disease

Protocol

Medical reports from 100 patients were excerpted for psychopathological symptoms and capacity disorders using a checklist. Additionally, structured assessment of capacity disorders was documented using the Mini-ICF-APP rating scale for all patients. Comparison was made between free-text clinical reports and structured assessments.

Expected Outcomes

Structured assessment would provide more comprehensive evaluation of capacity impairments compared to free-text clinical reports

Success Criteria

Ability to differentiate between patients fit for work and those unfit for work, and comprehensiveness of capacity impairment identification

Related Hypotheses (0)

No related hypotheses

Debate History (0)

No debates yet

Experiment Results (0)

No results recorded yet. Use POST /api/experiments/{id}/results to record a result.